All level 5 passages

The Choice You Could Not Have Avoided

Suppose Mira must decide whether to approve a proposal. Unknown to her, an observer named Sol has built a device that can detect the beginning of a decision. Sol wants approval. If Mira starts to choose rejection, the device will intervene and cause her to approve. If she begins choosing approval on her own, it will remain inactive.

Mira reads the proposal and approves it for reasons she accepts. The device never intervenes. Was she responsible for the choice? One argument says yes: her own judgment produced the action, and the hidden device played no role in the actual sequence. Another argument says no: because rejection was never truly possible, Mira lacked the freedom required for responsibility.

This kind of case is associated with philosopher Harry Frankfurt. It separates two ideas that often travel together: acting from one's own reasons and having open alternatives. In ordinary situations, we may assume a person could have done otherwise. Here, that assumption is removed while the person's deliberation remains.

The thought experiment does not settle every question about free will. Sol's perfect detector is imaginary, and critics disagree about whether Mira ever has even a tiny alternative. Its purpose is narrower. By changing one feature at a time, the case asks what our judgment of responsibility actually depends on: the path that produced an action, the availability of another path, or some combination of both.

Check your understanding

Answer 4 questions about this passage and see why each answer is right

Questions and pace mode are free with sign-in.

Sign in free to answer

About pace mode

Signed in, you can choose a pace from 150 to 400 words per minute. A highlight moves through the passage, then the questions check what you understood. Choose Off to read at your own speed.

Pace mode measures this reading session. It is not a measure of your overall reading ability.

Practice reading