All level 5 passages

The Stone Too Heavy to Lift

Can an all-powerful being create a stone so heavy that the being cannot lift it? If the answer is no, there seems to be something the being cannot create. If the answer is yes, there seems to be something the being cannot lift. This is known as the paradox of the stone, a puzzle about omnipotence.

The question appears to force either answer into a limit. Yet its force depends on what “all-powerful” and “can” mean. One response defines omnipotence as the ability to do anything logically possible. On this view, a task whose description contradicts itself is not a genuine task, just as drawing a square circle is not an especially difficult drawing.

That response opens further questions. Is “a stone an omnipotent being cannot lift” truly self-contradictory, or does calling it impossible merely protect the definition? Could a being voluntarily limit future power, and would that count as inability? Different accounts distinguish permanent capacities, temporary choices, and actions inconsistent with a being's nature.

The puzzle therefore does more than ask about weight. It tests whether ordinary action words continue to work when joined to an unlimited capacity. Language developed for agents with limits may produce unstable combinations when all limits are removed. A paradox can be useful without defeating a concept. Here, the stone reveals choices hidden inside a definition. Before deciding which horn of the dilemma wins, a reader must ask whether both horns describe coherent possibilities at all.

Check your understanding

Answer 4 questions about this passage and see why each answer is right

Questions and pace mode are free with sign-in.

Sign in free to answer

About pace mode

Signed in, you can choose a pace from 150 to 400 words per minute. A highlight moves through the passage, then the questions check what you understood. Choose Off to read at your own speed.

Pace mode measures this reading session. It is not a measure of your overall reading ability.

Practice reading