All level 3 passages

The Clock That Was Right by Accident

Mara enters the library and sees a wall clock showing 8:15. The clock has always been reliable, so she believes it is 8:15. It really is 8:15. Unknown to her, however, the clock stopped exactly twelve hours earlier.

Mara's belief is true, and she appears to have a good reason for it. Yet many people hesitate to say she knows the time. Her belief succeeds by coincidence, through luck: the broken clock happens to display the correct reading at that instant.

This is a Gettier-style problem. A traditional account described knowledge as justified true belief. Examples like Mara's suggest that truth, belief, and ordinary justification may all be present while knowledge is missing. Philosophers disagree about what additional condition can exclude the luck.

The puzzle does not show that reasons are useless. It asks whether a reason must connect to truth in the right way. Mara looks at evidence that normally works, but the evidence is not tracking time. Her answer is correct, but the source she used was not measuring the passing time.

Check your understanding

Answer 4 questions about this passage and see why each answer is right

Questions and pace mode are free with sign-in.

Sign in free to answer

About pace mode

Signed in, you can choose a pace from 150 to 400 words per minute. A highlight moves through the passage, then the questions check what you understood. Choose Off to read at your own speed.

Pace mode measures this reading session. It is not a measure of your overall reading ability.

Practice reading