What a cross section item asks
Picture slicing a block of cheese with one straight stroke of a knife. The flat face the knife leaves is the cross section. A test item draws a solid and a plane through it, and you pick the outline of that face.
On this site the solid is a cube or a rectangular block. A see-through sheet shows the cutting plane. Lines on the faces you can see show where the sheet meets them. The part of the cut behind the solid is not drawn, so you have to follow it round. The four choices always have three, four, five and six sides.
Where the format appears
At school. The Common Core math standards in the United States ask seventh graders to describe the two-dimensional figures that result from slicing three-dimensional figures, with rectangular prisms and pyramids as the examples (standard 7.G.A.3).
In research. Cheryl Cohen and Mary Hegarty built the Santa Barbara Solids Test, 30 multiple choice items in which you identify the cross section of a geometric solid. Its simplest solids are cones, cubes, cylinders, prisms and pyramids. Harder items join two solids or put one inside another.
In an older aptitude test. The Mental Cutting Test comes from the Special Aptitude Test in Spatial Relations, developed by the College Entrance Examination Board in the United States in 1939. The standard version has 25 problems. Each shows a drawing of a solid and a cutting plane, and you choose the section from five. In Japan, Kenjiro Suzuki of the University of Tokyo and colleagues have used it to measure spatial ability in graphics courses, and Emiko Tsutsumi used it with first-year students in Tokyo.
How to reason about it
Three facts do most of the work.
- Each face the plane crosses gives one side. A flat plane meets a flat face in a straight line. So the cut has as many sides as the plane crosses faces.
- A box has six faces, so a cut has three to six sides. Three is the fewest a closed shape can have. Six is every face.
- Opposite faces give parallel sides. The two opposite faces of a box are parallel, and one flat plane crosses them in parallel lines.
So count the faces, not the corners. Start with the lines drawn on the faces you can see. Then follow the sheet round the back and count the faces it must cross there. The sheet itself is drawn as a rectangle much bigger than the solid. Its outline is not the answer.
Four worked examples
Each example below is a real question from the cross sections practice on this site, drawn by the practice itself, and all four use the same cube. Cover the steps below each one and try it first. The second drawing is the one the practice shows after you answer: the whole cut shaded inside the cube, and the same shape laid flat beside it.
Example 1: a straight cut (Easy)
Which outline is the cut?
- Count the cut lines on the faces you can see: two.
- Follow the sheet around the back. It crosses two more faces you cannot see.
- Each crossed face gives the cut one side, so the cut has four sides: a square. That is option C.
The answer is C, a square. The cut runs parallel to two faces of a cube, so all four sides are as long as the cube’s edge.
Example 2: a cut tilted along one edge (Standard)
Which outline is the cut?
- Count the cut lines on the faces you can see: two.
- Follow the sheet around the back. It crosses two more faces you cannot see.
- Each crossed face gives the cut one side, so the cut has four sides: a rectangle. That is option B.
The answer is B, a rectangle. The cut still runs along the cube’s edges in one direction, so two sides are as long as an edge. In the other direction it crosses the cube on a slant, so those two sides are longer. Four right angles, two lengths: a rectangle, not a square.
Example 3: five sides (Standard)
Which outline is the cut?
- Count the cut lines on the faces you can see: three.
- Follow the sheet around the back. It crosses two more faces you cannot see.
- Each crossed face gives the cut one side, so the cut has five sides: a pentagon. That is option D.
The answer is D, a pentagon. Two pairs of its sides lie on opposite faces of the cube, and each of those pairs is parallel.
Example 4: six sides (Challenge)
Which outline is the cut?
- Count the cut lines on the faces you can see: three.
- Follow the sheet around the back. It crosses three more faces you cannot see.
- Each crossed face gives the cut one side, so the cut has six sides: a hexagon. That is option A.
The answer is A, a hexagon. All six faces are crossed. The three pairs of opposite faces give three pairs of parallel sides.
Common confusions
Square or rectangle. A cut parallel to a face of a cube is a square, as in example 1. The same cut of a longer box is a rectangle, and so is a tilted cut of a cube, as in example 2. On this site the four choices differ in their number of sides, so the count decides. Other tests can differ: some Mental Cutting Test problems turn on the lengths of the sides or the angles between them.
Four sides is not always a rectangle. Some Challenge cuts cross four faces at a slant and make a four-sided shape with no right angles. Count the sides first. Check angles only if a question needs them.
The hexagon. A cube can give more than squares, rectangles and triangles. A plane can cross all six faces and leave a hexagon. A cut through the middle of a cube, square to the line that joins two opposite corners, makes a regular hexagon, with six equal sides. The hexagons in the practice are tilted a little away from that, so their sides are not equal, as in example 4. Their opposite sides are still parallel.
Seeing the cut at a slant. The drawing shows the cut from an angle, so it looks squashed. The answer is the shape seen straight on. Cohen and Hegarty built wrong answers of exactly this kind into their test: the shape you would imagine without turning your point of view to face the cut. They also found more errors when the plane was tilted than when it was level or upright.
Cones and cylinders. The practice uses only boxes, but tests such as the Santa Barbara Solids Test include cones and cylinders. A cylinder cut straight across leaves a circle, and cut along its length it leaves a rectangle. A tilted cut that stays between the two ends leaves an ellipse. A cone cut parallel to its base leaves a circle, and a tilted cut that misses the base leaves an ellipse, as the conic sections show. A cut straight down through the tip meets the sloping surface in two straight lines and the base in a third, so it leaves a triangle.
Drawing the lines is not enough. In Tsutsumi's study, students who drew the cut lines on each solid before answering did not score higher than on the standard version. Lines help only once you count them and close the shape.
How to practice it here
Start with the lesson Cut a solid. Its example step has a tilted cut that you slide through a cube by hand, so you can watch the number of sides change as the cut moves. Then play the cross sections practice. Each round is six questions, with one cube and five boxes of other proportions. The levels change which cuts you get:
- Easy: three straight slices with four sides and three corner cuts with three.
- Standard: three four-sided cuts, one corner cut and two cuts with five sides.
- Challenge: one four-sided cut, two with five sides and three with six.
There is no time limit and no bonus for speed. Your answer locks when you choose it. Then the practice shades the whole cut, draws it flat beside the solid, and lets you turn the view. Before you go on, find each side of the flat shape on the face it came from. The score is the number right out of six. It describes this practice on that day, nothing wider.
Related practices on this site
- Cube views. Read a solid from its top and front views.
- Match the opening. Find the outline a whole solid makes as it passes through a hole.
Questions people ask
What is a cross section test?
A cross section test shows a solid with a flat cut through it and asks what shape the cut leaves. Research versions include the Santa Barbara Solids Test, with 30 multiple choice items, and the Mental Cutting Test, which comes from a 1939 aptitude test in spatial relations. In US schools, standard 7.G.A.3 asks seventh graders to describe the shapes that slicing a solid leaves.
How do you find the shape of a cross section?
Count the faces the cut passes through. A flat cut meets each flat face in one straight line, so the shape has as many sides as the cut crosses faces. Start with the lines drawn on the faces you can see. Then follow the cut round the back and count the faces it must cross there. Opposite faces give parallel sides.
What cross sections can a cube have?
A cube has six faces, so a flat cut has three to six sides. A corner cut gives a triangle. A cut parallel to a face gives a square, and a cut tilted along one edge gives a rectangle. Some cuts cross five faces and give five sides. A cut through the middle, square to the line joining two opposite corners, gives a regular hexagon.
What is the cross section of a cylinder or a cone?
A cylinder cut straight across leaves a circle, and cut along its length it leaves a rectangle. A tilted cut that stays between the two ends leaves an ellipse. A cone cut parallel to its base leaves a circle, and a tilted cut that misses the base leaves an ellipse. A cut straight down through the tip of a cone leaves a triangle.
Why are cross section questions hard?
The cut is drawn at a slant, so it looks squashed, but the answer is the shape seen straight on. Cohen and Hegarty built wrong answers of exactly that kind into their test, and they found more errors when the cutting plane was tilted than when it was level or upright. Drawing the cut lines is not enough. Count them and close the shape.
Sources
- Illustrative Mathematics. Common Core standard 7.G.A.3, slicing three-dimensional figures.
- Cohen, C. A. and Hegarty, M. (2012). Inferring cross sections of 3D objects: a new spatial thinking test. Learning and Individual Differences, 22, 868 to 874.
- Cohen, C. A. and Hegarty, M. (2007). Sources of difficulty in imagining cross sections of 3D objects. Proceedings of the 29th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society, 179 to 184.
- Tsutsumi, E. (2004). A Mental Cutting Test using drawings of intersections. Journal for Geometry and Graphics, 8(1), 117 to 126.
- Wolfram MathWorld. Cube, Cylinder and Conic Section.