Purpose first, then limits
Start with a familiar use; it is a good first idea. For the second, change what the object is for, not only where it is. Holding pencils on a desk and holding spoons in a drawer serve the same purpose in two places. The practice suggests three directions: hold or organize, mark or show, or tell a story.
At the deeper levels a limit is added, such as keeping the cup upright or keeping its inside empty. Check your idea against each limit, one at a time. Keep the parts that fit and change only the part that breaks a limit.
Your own ideas get no score, and many different ideas are good. Only the practice’s small worked example has one answer: whether a given use meets the limits.
1Name what your first idea is for.
2Choose a different purpose, not only a different place.
3Check each limit on its own; change only what breaks it.
A spoon without food
The first idea is the familiar one: stir a drink.
Now the limit: use no food or drink. Stirring needs a drink, so that idea needs a change. Keep the spoon and change its purpose to marking or showing: draw its curved outline. Drawing needs no food or drink, so it fits.
A cup with two limits
The cup has two limits: keep the cup upright, and keep its inside empty. Check each use against each limit on its own.
Try it
Which use meets both limits?
- Hold pencils
- Mark a round space
Show the answer
Mark a round space
Right. The upright cup marks a round space on a desk, and nothing needs to go inside it. Each limit, checked on its own, fits.
Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.
Practice Many uses for one object