Change the purpose, then check each limit

A different use serves a different purpose, and a revised idea keeps what fits and changes only what breaks a limit

Purpose first, then limits

A use for a cupHold or organizeHold pencils on a desk.Mark or showUse its round outline as a shape to draw.Tell a storyImagine it as a tiny house in a story.
Three directions, three different purposes.

Start with a familiar use; it is a good first idea. For the second, change what the object is for, not only where it is.

More

Holding pencils on a desk and holding spoons in a drawer serve the same purpose in two places. The practice suggests three directions: hold or organize, mark or show, or tell a story.

At the deeper levels a limit is added, such as keeping the cup upright or keeping its inside empty. Check your idea against each limit, one at a time. Keep the parts that fit and change only the part that breaks a limit.

Your own ideas get no score, and many different ideas are good. Only the practice’s small worked example has one answer: whether a given use meets the limits.

1Name what your first idea is for.

2Choose a different purpose, not only a different place.

3Check each limit on its own; change only what breaks it.

Lesson help

Change what the object is for, then check each limit on its own and change only what breaks it.

About this lesson

Try the method in a practice when you are ready.

Report

Purpose first, then limits

Start with a familiar use; it is a good first idea. For the second, change what the object is for, not only where it is. Holding pencils on a desk and holding spoons in a drawer serve the same purpose in two places. The practice suggests three directions: hold or organize, mark or show, or tell a story.

At the deeper levels a limit is added, such as keeping the cup upright or keeping its inside empty. Check your idea against each limit, one at a time. Keep the parts that fit and change only the part that breaks a limit.

Your own ideas get no score, and many different ideas are good. Only the practice’s small worked example has one answer: whether a given use meets the limits.

1Name what your first idea is for.

2Choose a different purpose, not only a different place.

3Check each limit on its own; change only what breaks it.

A use for a cupHold or organizeHold pencils on a desk.Mark or showUse its round outline as a shape to draw.Tell a storyImagine it as a tiny house in a story.
Three directions, three different purposes.

A spoon without food

The first idea is the familiar one: stir a drink.

Now the limit: use no food or drink. Stirring needs a drink, so that idea needs a change. Keep the spoon and change its purpose to marking or showing: draw its curved outline. Drawing needs no food or drink, so it fits.

Use no food ordrink.Stir a drinkNeeds a changeDraw its curved outlineFits
One limit, checked against each use.

A cup with two limits

The cup has two limits: keep the cup upright, and keep its inside empty. Check each use against each limit on its own.

Keep the cupupright.Keep its insideempty.Hold pencils??Mark a round space??
Two uses and two limits.

Try it

Which use meets both limits?

  1. Hold pencils
  2. Mark a round space
Show the answer

Mark a round space

Right. The upright cup marks a round space on a desk, and nothing needs to go inside it. Each limit, checked on its own, fits.

Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.

Practice Many uses for one object

Sign in free

Practice without limits and keep your progress.