The right fact from the right line
Improve the answer gives a short source, a brief that says what to tell someone, and two responses. You choose the better one, say what is wrong with the other, and choose a repair. The better response follows the brief; being longer or more careful is not what decides it.
Start with the brief: which facts does it ask for, and for whom? Then find the one line of the source that applies to each fact. Sources often hold the same kind of fact for different cases: weekdays and Sunday, one branch and another, a pass and no pass.
Check each fact in each response against its line. The weaker response usually has the right kind of fact taken from the wrong line.
1List the facts the brief asks for.
2Find the source line that applies to each one.
3Check each response, fact by fact, against those lines.
Breakfast on Sunday
Source: The Riverside Café serves breakfast from seven until eleven on weekdays. On Sunday, breakfast starts at nine and ends at noon. The café is closed on Saturday.
Brief: Tell a friend until what time they can order breakfast on Sunday.
Response 1: On Sunday, breakfast is served until eleven.
Response 2: On Sunday, breakfast is served until noon.
Eleven or noon
The brief asks for one fact: when breakfast ends on Sunday. The source has two closing times. Eleven is on the weekday line; the Sunday line says noon.
Response 1 says eleven, a real closing time from the wrong line. Response 2 says noon, from the Sunday line, so it is the better answer, and the repair keeps Sunday and changes only the time.
Breakfast on Sunday
Source: The Riverside Café serves breakfast from seven until eleven on weekdays. On Sunday, breakfast starts at nine and ends at noon. The café is closed on Saturday.
Brief: Tell a friend until what time they can order breakfast on Sunday.
Response 1: On Sunday, breakfast is served until eleven.
Response 2: On Sunday, breakfast is served until noon.
A single visit to the pool
The visitor has no pass. Find the line that applies to them before you compare the responses.
A single visit to the pool
Source: The town pool has two entrances. Swimmers with a monthly pass may use either entrance. Swimmers paying for a single visit must buy a ticket at the main entrance on Mill Lane. The pool opens at eight.
Brief: Tell a visitor without a pass how to get in.
Response 1: Buy a single ticket at the main entrance on Mill Lane; the pool opens at eight.
Response 2: Use either entrance and buy a ticket there; the pool opens at eight.
Try it
Which response better follows the brief?
- Response 1
- Response 2
Show the answer
Response 1
Right. The visitor pays for a single visit, so the line that applies says the main entrance on Mill Lane. Either entrance is only for pass holders.
Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.
Practice Improve the answer