Find the first wrong step

Check each step against the problem and the step before it, and stop at the first that fails

One step at a time, in order

The problemThree tickets cost $4 each. A booking fee of $3 ischarged once for the whole order. Find the total.1Each ticket costs $4.2Three tickets cost 3 × 4 = $12.3Add the fee for each ticket: 12 + 3 × 3 = $21.4The total is $21.
Four steps. Check them in order.

A worked solution is a list of steps. Each step should follow from the problem and from the steps before it. Check them in order, one at a time, against those two things only.

More

Stop at the first step that does not follow. Later steps may be wrong too, but often only because they carry the first mistake forward. A step can use the right method with the wrong number, so check the arithmetic as well as the idea.

Then repair that step and redo every step after it. The practice also asks you to use the repaired method in a new situation, so name what the mistake was, not only where it is.

1Check step 1 against the problem.

2Check each next step against the problem and the step before.

3Stop at the first that fails, then repair it.

Lesson help

Check each step against the problem and the step before it; the first that fails is the one to repair.

About this lesson

Try the method in a practice when you are ready.

Report

One step at a time, in order

A worked solution is a list of steps. Each step should follow from the problem and from the steps before it. Check them in order, one at a time, against those two things only.

Stop at the first step that does not follow. Later steps may be wrong too, but often only because they carry the first mistake forward. A step can use the right method with the wrong number, so check the arithmetic as well as the idea.

Then repair that step and redo every step after it. The practice also asks you to use the repaired method in a new situation, so name what the mistake was, not only where it is.

1Check step 1 against the problem.

2Check each next step against the problem and the step before.

3Stop at the first that fails, then repair it.

The problemThree tickets cost $4 each. A booking fee of $3 ischarged once for the whole order. Find the total.1Each ticket costs $4.2Three tickets cost 3 × 4 = $12.3Add the fee for each ticket: 12 + 3 × 3 = $21.4The total is $21.
Four steps. Check them in order.

A fee charged once

Step 1 repeats the price, so it follows. Step 2 multiplies three tickets by $4 to get $12, which is right.

Step 3 adds the fee three times. The problem says the fee is charged once for the whole order. This is the first error.

Step 4 is also wrong, but only because it copies step 3. Repair step 3 to 12 + 3 = $15, and step 4 becomes $15.

The problemThree tickets cost $4 each. A booking fee of $3 ischarged once for the whole order. Find the total.1Each ticket costs $4.2Three tickets cost 3 × 4 = $12.3Add the fee for each ticket: 12 + 3 × 3 = $21.first error4The total is $21.carried
Step 3 is the first error. Step 4 carries it forward.

Across the hour

Check the steps in order. Which one is the first that does not follow?

The problemA train leaves at 10:50. The trip takes 25minutes. Find the arrival time.1From 10:50 to 11:00 is 10 minutes.2That leaves 25 − 10 = 5 minutes.3So the train arrives at 11:05.
Three steps.

Try it

Which is the first incorrect step?

  1. Step 2
  2. Step 3
Show the answer

Step 2

Right. Step 1 is true. Step 2 subtracts wrongly: 25 − 10 is 15. Step 3 adds correctly from step 2’s number, so it is wrong only because it carries the mistake. The train arrives at 11:15.

Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.

Practice Repair a worked solution

Sign in free

Practice without limits and keep your progress.