Paths, then proof
Rebuild the story shows a few everyday events one at a time, with where each object is. Then you put the events back in the order you saw and decide whether a detail is supported by the story.
Follow the objects. For each one, say its path as places: “umbrella: bench, coat stand, Noor.” A path fixes the order of the moves, because an object has to reach a place before anyone takes it from there. Then fit the other events between the moves they came between.
For the detail, name the event that shows it. If you can point to one, it is supported. If the detail is only likely, such as who wrote a note, who owns the keys or what is in a closed box, no event shows it, and it is not supported.
1Say each object's path as places.
2Fit the other events between the moves.
3For the detail, name the event that shows it.
An umbrella at the library
1. Noor leaves the umbrella. Umbrella: Bench.
2. Sam moves the umbrella. Umbrella: Coat stand.
An umbrella at the library
The umbrella's path is bench, coat stand, Noor. So Noor leaves it first, Sam moves it second, and Noor takes it last. Noor asking Sam happens while it is on the coat stand, so it goes third.
The detail: Sam moved the umbrella to the coat stand. Event 2 shows exactly that, so it is supported by the story.
An umbrella at the library
1. Noor leaves the umbrella. Umbrella: Bench.
2. Sam moves the umbrella. Umbrella: Coat stand.
3. Noor asks Sam. Umbrella: Coat stand.
4. Noor takes the umbrella. Umbrella: Noor.
Does the story support this detail?
Sam moved the umbrella to the coat stand.
A note and a blue book
Two paths: the book goes table, Leo; the note goes desk, Leo. You have put the four events in order. Now the detail.
A note and a blue book
1. Leo reads the book. Book: Table.
2. Ana leaves a note. Book: Table; Note: Desk.
3. Leo closes the book. Book: Leo; Note: Desk.
4. Ana hands over the note. Book: Leo; Note: Leo.
Does the story support this detail?
Ana wrote the note that morning.
Try it
Does the story support this detail: Ana wrote the note that morning?
- Supported by the story
- Not supported
Show the answer
Not supported
Right. The story shows Ana leaving and handing over the note, never writing it, so no event supports the detail.
Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.
Practice Rebuild the story