Give every object one possible place

Before you send directions, ask of each instruction how many places it leaves; a clear message leaves the listener exactly one arrangement

How many places does it leave?

???
Cup: top row. The listener could put the cup in any of three places.

Give clear directions shows you a few objects on a board of nine places. You choose an instruction for each object, and a listener, or you later, rebuilds the board from your message alone. The practice tells you whether the message describes one arrangement or allows more than one.

More

So test each instruction before you send it: if I only had these words, how many places could the object go? Top row leaves three. Middle column leaves three. Top left leaves one.

An instruction can also lean on another object, such as one space below the cup. That works once the object it leans on has one place of its own. Start with one exact place and build from there.

1Take each instruction on its own.

2Count the places it leaves the listener.

3Send the message when every object has exactly one.

Lesson help

Count the places each instruction leaves, and send the message when every object has exactly one.

About this lesson

Try the method in a practice when you are ready.

Report

How many places does it leave?

Give clear directions shows you a few objects on a board of nine places. You choose an instruction for each object, and a listener, or you later, rebuilds the board from your message alone. The practice tells you whether the message describes one arrangement or allows more than one.

So test each instruction before you send it: if I only had these words, how many places could the object go? Top row leaves three. Middle column leaves three. Top left leaves one.

An instruction can also lean on another object, such as one space below the cup. That works once the object it leans on has one place of its own. Start with one exact place and build from there.

1Take each instruction on its own.

2Count the places it leaves the listener.

3Send the message when every object has exactly one.

???
Cup: top row. The listener could put the cup in any of three places.

One exact place, then lean on it

The message: Cup: Middle. Apple: one space left of the cup. Key: one space below the apple.

The cup has one place, the middle. One space left of the cup is then one place too, middle left. One space below the apple is bottom left. Every object has exactly one place, so the listener can rebuild the board without guessing.

Each instruction leaves one place, so there is one arrangement.

Two messages for one board

Message A: Cup: Top left. Key: Middle column. Flower: Bottom right.

Message B: Cup: Top left. Key: Middle. Flower: Bottom right.

Both are true of this board. Count the places each instruction leaves.

The board the speaker sees.

Try it

Which message lets the listener rebuild the board without guessing?

  1. Message A
  2. Message B
Show the answer

Message B

Right. In Message B every instruction leaves one place. In Message A, middle column leaves the key three.

Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.

Practice Give clear directions

Sign in free

Practice without limits and keep your progress.