One choice, two checks
Two texts, one question gives two short accounts of the same matter, written by different people, and asks what they support together. Each answer is backed by a sentence from each text.
A wrong choice usually fits one text well. It repeats what one writer wants, and the other text quietly rules it out. So one check is not enough.
Take each choice through two checks: what does text A say about it, and what does text B say? Keep the choice that both support and neither rules out.
1Read both texts before you choose.
2Check each choice against A, then B.
3Keep the one both support and neither rules out.
Should the market move indoors?
A. A stallholder
I have sold vegetables at the Saturday market for nine years. In January and February my takings fall by about half, and on wet days I pack up early, because the car park is open to the wind. I would move to the sports hall for those two months if the rent stayed the same.
B. The sports hall manager
The hall is free on Saturday mornings from December to March, and it has room for twenty stalls. The market has thirty, so we could not take them all at once. We could offer the space at the usual market rent if the stalls took turns.
What both accept
What do both writers accept? The choices: every stall should move into the hall; the market should stay in the car park all winter; the market can use the hall at its usual rent.
The first fits nothing in A and B rules it out: the hall has room for twenty of thirty stalls. The second is ruled out by A, who would move for two months. The third passes both checks: A would move if the rent stayed the same, and B offers the usual market rent.
Should the market move indoors?
A. A stallholder
I have sold vegetables at the Saturday market for nine years. In January and February my takings fall by about half, and on wet days I pack up early, because the car park is open to the wind. I would move to the sports hall for those two months if the rent stayed the same.
B. The sports hall manager
The hall is free on Saturday mornings from December to March, and it has room for twenty stalls. The market has thirty, so we could not take them all at once. We could offer the space at the usual market rent if the stalls took turns.
A plan for both
Which plan fits both accounts? Take each choice through both texts.
Should the market move indoors?
A. A stallholder
I have sold vegetables at the Saturday market for nine years. In January and February my takings fall by about half, and on wet days I pack up early, because the car park is open to the wind. I would move to the sports hall for those two months if the rent stayed the same.
B. The sports hall manager
The hall is free on Saturday mornings from December to March, and it has room for twenty stalls. The market has thirty, so we could not take them all at once. We could offer the space at the usual market rent if the stalls took turns.
Try it
Which plan fits both accounts?
- Move the whole market into the hall for January and February.
- Use the hall in January and February, with the stalls taking turns.
Show the answer
Use the hall in January and February, with the stalls taking turns.
Right. A would move for January and February, and B can offer the hall if the stalls take turns. Both support it.
Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.
Practice Two texts, one question