Let each white cancel a green, then read the lead

Every green moves the chance of Bag A by the same step and every white undoes one, so the estimate depends only on how many more greens than whites you have seen

Count the lead

Bag A7 green, 3 whiteBag B3 green, 7 white
One of these two bags was picked at random.

Update your belief shows two bags. At Level 1 Bag A holds 7 green balls and 3 white, Bag B the reverse. One was picked at random, so each starts at 50%.

More

You draw a ball, see it, and it goes back; after each draw you move the slider for the chance that it is Bag A. Your last estimate counts as close within 15 points of the exact chance.

Each green makes Bag A more likely by the same step, and each white makes it less likely by that step. So a green and a white cancel, whatever the order. Keep one number as you draw: greens minus whites, the lead.

Then read the chance from the lead. With bags of 7 and 3, a lead of one green gives 70%, two give 84%, three 93%. A lead of none is back to 50%, and a lead of whites gives the same numbers for Bag B.

1Start at 50%.

2Keep the lead: greens minus whites.

3Read the chance from the lead, not from the last ball.

Lesson help

Let each white cancel a green and read the chance from the lead that is left.

About this lesson

Try the method in a practice when you are ready.

Report

Count the lead

Update your belief shows two bags. At Level 1 Bag A holds 7 green balls and 3 white, Bag B the reverse. One was picked at random, so each starts at 50%. You draw a ball, see it, and it goes back; after each draw you move the slider for the chance that it is Bag A. Your last estimate counts as close within 15 points of the exact chance.

Each green makes Bag A more likely by the same step, and each white makes it less likely by that step. So a green and a white cancel, whatever the order. Keep one number as you draw: greens minus whites, the lead.

Then read the chance from the lead. With bags of 7 and 3, a lead of one green gives 70%, two give 84%, three 93%. A lead of none is back to 50%, and a lead of whites gives the same numbers for Bag B.

1Start at 50%.

2Keep the lead: greens minus whites.

3Read the chance from the lead, not from the last ball.

Bag A7 green, 3 whiteBag B3 green, 7 white
One of these two bags was picked at random.

Four draws

Green: a lead of one, 70%. Green again: a lead of two, 84%. A white cancels one green: a lead of one again, 70%.

One more green: a lead of two, 84%. The last estimate, 84% for Bag A, is the one that counts, and it matches the exact chance.

Bag A7 green, 3 whiteBag B3 green, 7 whiteDrawnGGWG50%70%84%70%84%
The exact chance after each draw follows the lead.

Bags of 8 and 2

Level 3: Bag A holds 8 green and 2 white, Bag B the reverse. With these bags a lead of one green gives 80%, two give 94%, three 98%. Five balls have been drawn.

Bag A8 green, 2 whiteBag B2 green, 8 whiteDrawnGGWGW
Five draws, in order.

Try it

After these five draws, where do you set the slider?

  1. About 80% for Bag A
  2. About 98% for Bag A
Show the answer

About 80% for Bag A

Right. Three greens and two whites: the whites cancel two of the greens and leave a lead of one, which with bags of 8 and 2 is 80%.

Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.

Practice Update your belief

Sign in free

Practice without limits and keep your progress.