Pool the clues, then chain them

No one packet settles the order Put every participant's clues together, place any fixed position first, then link the left-of clues into one chain

One packet is never enough

Participant 1

  • Triangle is somewhere to the left of Circle.
  • Circle is somewhere to the left of Square.

Participant 2

  • Diamond is somewhere to the left of Triangle.
Participant 1 alone leaves the Diamond free to go anywhere.

Each participant holds part of the clues, and the round is built so that no single packet allows only one order. So before anyone moves a shape, everyone says their clues aloud and the group writes them all down.

More

Then use the clues that fix a place first: a shape in position 1 goes there and stays. Next, link the left-of clues into one chain. If the Triangle is left of the Circle and the Circle is left of the Square, then Triangle, Circle, Square run in that order, though not always side by side.

Fit the remaining shapes into the chain where every clue allows, and check each clue against the finished row.

1Pool every packet.

2Place fixed positions first.

3Join the left-of clues into one chain, then check every clue.

Lesson help

Pool every packet first, place the fixed positions, then join the left-of clues into one chain.

About this lesson

Try the method in a practice when you are ready.

Report

One packet is never enough

Each participant holds part of the clues, and the round is built so that no single packet allows only one order. So before anyone moves a shape, everyone says their clues aloud and the group writes them all down.

Then use the clues that fix a place first: a shape in position 1 goes there and stays. Next, link the left-of clues into one chain. If the Triangle is left of the Circle and the Circle is left of the Square, then Triangle, Circle, Square run in that order, though not always side by side.

Fit the remaining shapes into the chain where every clue allows, and check each clue against the finished row.

1Pool every packet.

2Place fixed positions first.

3Join the left-of clues into one chain, then check every clue.

Participant 1

  • Triangle is somewhere to the left of Circle.
  • Circle is somewhere to the left of Square.

Participant 2

  • Diamond is somewhere to the left of Triangle.
Participant 1 alone leaves the Diamond free to go anywhere.

Two packets, one order

Participant 1 chains Triangle, Circle, Square. Alone, that still allows four orders, because the Diamond could go in any of four places.

Participant 2 adds that the Diamond is left of the Triangle. Now the Diamond is ahead of the whole chain: Diamond, Triangle, Circle, Square. Every clue holds, and no other order does.

1Diamond2Triangle3Circle4Square
Diamond, Triangle, Circle, Square: all three clues hold.

Which shape is last?

Four shapes: Circle, Triangle, Square and Diamond. Pool both packets before you answer.

Participant 1

  • Diamond is somewhere to the left of Circle.
  • Triangle is somewhere to the left of Diamond.

Participant 2

  • Square is in position 1, counting from the left.
Two participants, three clues.

Try it

Which shape is in position 4, on the right?

  1. Square
  2. Circle
Show the answer

Circle

Right. The Square is fixed in position 1. Participant 1's clues chain Triangle, Diamond, Circle, which fills positions 2, 3 and 4. The Circle is last.

Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.

Practice Shared clues

Sign in free

Practice without limits and keep your progress.