Recall the problem, then what changed it

Before you hide the text, find its problem and what changed it; recall those two ideas first, then add details

Two ideas carry the passage

The bike racks

The bike shed at the school had forty racks, but most mornings a dozen bikes were left leaning against the fence. The racks were full by eight, and children who came later had nowhere to lock up.

The caretaker walked along the racks and found that many of them held bikes that never moved: old ones that nobody rode any more. After a note went home, families took eleven of them away. The next Monday every bike fit inside, and no new racks had been bought.

A short passage of two paragraphs, as the practice shows it.

Read, close, recall asks you to read a short passage once, hide it, and write what you remember. Then it shows Ideas to look for, and you mark the ones you recalled.

More

Those ideas are not the vivid details. In these passages there are two: the problem, and what changed it and why that worked. A recall full of true details can still miss both.

So as you read, ask two questions: what was going wrong, and what made the difference? Write those two ideas first, in your own words. Add details after, if you remember them.

1Find the problem as you read.

2Find what changed it, and why that worked.

3Write those two ideas first, then details.

Lesson help

Recall what was going wrong and what changed it before any detail.

About this lesson

Try the method in a practice when you are ready.

Report

Two ideas carry the passage

Read, close, recall asks you to read a short passage once, hide it, and write what you remember. Then it shows Ideas to look for, and you mark the ones you recalled.

Those ideas are not the vivid details. In these passages there are two: the problem, and what changed it and why that worked. A recall full of true details can still miss both.

So as you read, ask two questions: what was going wrong, and what made the difference? Write those two ideas first, in your own words. Add details after, if you remember them.

1Find the problem as you read.

2Find what changed it, and why that worked.

3Write those two ideas first, then details.

The bike racks

The bike shed at the school had forty racks, but most mornings a dozen bikes were left leaning against the fence. The racks were full by eight, and children who came later had nowhere to lock up.

The caretaker walked along the racks and found that many of them held bikes that never moved: old ones that nobody rode any more. After a note went home, families took eleven of them away. The next Monday every bike fit inside, and no new racks had been bought.

A short passage of two paragraphs, as the practice shows it.

The bike racks

A first recall might say: forty racks, a fence, a note went home. All true, and none of them is the point.

Ask the two questions. What was going wrong? Children who came later had nowhere to lock up, because the racks were full. What made the difference? Old bikes nobody rode were taken away, so every bike fit with no new racks. That recall marks both ideas.

The bike racks

The bike shed at the school had forty racks, but most mornings a dozen bikes were left leaning against the fence. The racks were full by eight, and children who came later had nowhere to lock up.

The caretaker walked along the racks and found that many of them held bikes that never moved: old ones that nobody rode any more. After a note went home, families took eleven of them away. The next Monday every bike fit inside, and no new racks had been bought.

Ideas to look for

1. Children who came later had nowhere to lock their bikes, because the racks were full.

2. Many racks held old bikes nobody rode; once they were taken away, every bike fit without new racks.

The two ideas: the problem, then what changed it.

The town hall bell

Read the passage and ask the two questions. Then compare two recalls of it.

The town hall bell

In the old town hall, the bell at the end of each meeting was so loud that people in the next room jumped. Someone wanted to take it down, but the hall used it to tell everyone the room was free.

Lin wrapped a strip of felt around the hammer that struck the bell. It still rang, and it could still be heard along the corridor, but nobody jumped any more. The hall kept its signal and lost only the noise it did not need.

A new passage.

Try it

Which recall would mark both ideas to look for?

  1. The town hall was old. Lin used a strip of felt. The bell could be heard along the corridor.
  2. The bell was too loud, but the hall needed it to say the room was free. Felt on the hammer made it softer, so it still worked as a signal.
Show the answer

The bell was too loud, but the hall needed it to say the room was free. Felt on the hammer made it softer, so it still worked as a signal.

Right. It gives the problem, a loud bell the hall still needed, and the change, felt that softened it while it kept working.

Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.

Practice Read, close, recall

Sign in free

Practice without limits and keep your progress.