Hold a light where the maps differ

Predict each map’s lights before you run, and choose the experiment where they disagree

Predict, then run

Map 1ABCMap 2ABCMap 3ABC
With nothing held, all three maps light everything.

A light with no arrow coming in is on. A light with arrows coming in is on only when all of them come from lights that are on. Holding a light off overrides its arrows in, and its arrows out carry the off signal onward.

More

Several connection maps could be the real one. Before you run an experiment, work out what every light would show on each map. If two maps predict the same lights, that experiment cannot tell them apart.

Run an experiment where the maps disagree, then drop every map that does not match what you saw. Choose a map only when it is the last one left.

1For one experiment, predict every light on every map.

2Run it only if the predictions differ.

3Drop the maps that disagree with the result.

Lesson help

Run the experiment where the remaining maps predict different lights.

About this lesson

Try the method in a practice when you are ready.

Report

Predict, then run

A light with no arrow coming in is on. A light with arrows coming in is on only when all of them come from lights that are on. Holding a light off overrides its arrows in, and its arrows out carry the off signal onward.

Several connection maps could be the real one. Before you run an experiment, work out what every light would show on each map. If two maps predict the same lights, that experiment cannot tell them apart.

Run an experiment where the maps disagree, then drop every map that does not match what you saw. Choose a map only when it is the last one left.

1For one experiment, predict every light on every map.

2Run it only if the predictions differ.

3Drop the maps that disagree with the result.

Map 1ABCMap 2ABCMap 3ABC
With nothing held, all three maps light everything.

One experiment, three maps

With nothing held, every light is on in all three maps, so the starting picture rules nothing out.

Hold A off. In map 1, B goes off and C stays on. In map 2, C goes off and B stays on. In map 3, both go off. Each map predicts a different picture, so this one experiment names the map.

Map 1ABCMap 2ABCMap 3ABC
A is held off. Each map predicts a different result.

A chain or a fork

Two maps are left: a chain, A to B to C, and a fork, A to B and A to C. Predict both maps for each choice before you pick.

Map 1ABCMap 2ABC
Both maps light everything when nothing is held.

Try it

Which experiment tells the two maps apart?

  1. Hold B off
  2. Hold A off
Show the answer

Hold B off

Right. With B held off, the chain turns C off, because C listens only to B. In the fork, C listens to A, which is still on, so C stays on.

Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.

Practice What controls what?

Sign in free

Practice without limits and keep your progress.