Split the coins three ways

Every weighing has three results, so put a group on each pan and leave a group off

Three results, three groups

1234LeftRightOff56
Two coins on each pan, two off.

A weighing can end three ways: the left pan heavier, the right pan heavier, or the pans balanced. A good weighing uses all three. Put the same number of coins on each pan and leave a group off.

More

When the odd coin is known to be heavier, the heavier pan holds it, and a balance means it is one of the coins left off. So split the coins that could still be odd into three groups as equal as you can: one on each pan and one off.

Before you weigh, count how many coins each result would leave. Choose the weighing whose largest count is smallest. Conclude only when one coin fits every result you recorded.

1Put equal numbers on each pan.

2Leave a group off: a balance points to it.

3Count what each of the three results would leave.

Lesson help

Split what is still possible into three groups, because a weighing has three results.

About this lesson

Try the method in a practice when you are ready.

Report

Three results, three groups

A weighing can end three ways: the left pan heavier, the right pan heavier, or the pans balanced. A good weighing uses all three. Put the same number of coins on each pan and leave a group off.

When the odd coin is known to be heavier, the heavier pan holds it, and a balance means it is one of the coins left off. So split the coins that could still be odd into three groups as equal as you can: one on each pan and one off.

Before you weigh, count how many coins each result would leave. Choose the weighing whose largest count is smallest. Conclude only when one coin fits every result you recorded.

1Put equal numbers on each pan.

2Leave a group off: a balance points to it.

3Count what each of the three results would leave.

1234LeftRightOff56
Two coins on each pan, two off.

Six coins in two weighings

Six coins, one heavier. Weigh 1 and 2 against 3 and 4, with 5 and 6 off.

If the left pan is heavier, the coin is 1 or 2. If the right is heavier, it is 3 or 4. If they balance, it is 5 or 6. Every result leaves two coins.

Now weigh one of those two against the other. The heavier pan holds the odd coin. Two weighings in every case.

At the hardest level the odd coin may be heavier or lighter. A result then leaves more explanations, but the same count guides the choice.

1234LeftRightOff56
Each of the three results leaves two coins.

Nine coins

Nine coins, one heavier, and a target of two weighings. For each first weighing, count what each result would leave.

LeftRightOff123456789
Nine coins, none weighed yet.

Try it

Which first weighing can always finish in two?

  1. Coins 1, 2 and 3 against 4, 5 and 6
  2. Coins 1, 2, 3 and 4 against 5, 6, 7 and 8
Show the answer

Coins 1, 2 and 3 against 4, 5 and 6

Right. Each result leaves three coins: 1 to 3, 4 to 6, or 7 to 9. Then weigh one of the three against another with the third off. Two weighings in every case.

Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.

Practice Weigh the evidence

Sign in free

Practice without limits and keep your progress.