Lift the stick that passes over at every crossing

Follow each stick from end to end A stick with a gap at any crossing has another on top of it; the one with no gap anywhere lifts first

A gap means something is on top

AABBCCDD
Four sticks. Each letter marks both ends of its stick.

Over and under draws a pile of sticks. Where two cross, the lower stick shows a gap and the upper one runs across it unbroken. You may lift a stick only when no other stick lies on it.

More

So test one stick at a time. Follow it from end to end and look at every crossing. If it has a gap at even one crossing, another stick lies on it, and it cannot go first.

In these piles every stick crosses every other, so exactly one stick passes over at all of its crossings. That is the first lift. For a whole order, lift it away in your mind and test the sticks that are left in the same way.

1Follow one stick from end to end.

2A gap at any crossing means another stick is on top.

3Lift the stick with no gap.

Lesson help

Follow each stick end to end; the first to lift is the one with no gap at any crossing.

About this lesson

Try the method in a practice when you are ready.

Report

A gap means something is on top

Over and under draws a pile of sticks. Where two cross, the lower stick shows a gap and the upper one runs across it unbroken. You may lift a stick only when no other stick lies on it.

So test one stick at a time. Follow it from end to end and look at every crossing. If it has a gap at even one crossing, another stick lies on it, and it cannot go first.

In these piles every stick crosses every other, so exactly one stick passes over at all of its crossings. That is the first lift. For a whole order, lift it away in your mind and test the sticks that are left in the same way.

1Follow one stick from end to end.

2A gap at any crossing means another stick is on top.

3Lift the stick with no gap.

AABBCCDD
Four sticks. Each letter marks both ends of its stick.

D has no gap

Follow D from end to end: it passes over A, B and C, with no gap anywhere. Follow B: it passes over A and C, but it has a gap where D crosses it.

C and A have gaps too. D is the only stick with nothing on it, so D lifts first.

AABBCCDD
D, in green, runs unbroken over every crossing.

A new pile

Follow B and C from end to end, and look for a gap at every crossing.

AABBCCDD
Four sticks, as the practice shows them.

Try it

Which stick can you lift first without moving another?

  1. B
  2. C
Show the answer

C

Right. C crosses A, B and D and passes over each of them, so nothing lies on it.

Enable JavaScript to answer interactively and save your place.

Practice Over and under

Sign in free

Practice without limits and keep your progress.